13-02-2015, 15:31
Hello again,
I think that I could give a better answer, so, I will try to add some info based on what I already experienced.
The first antenna in my opinion will do the job if the TX is not that far away form the RX and at the same time, probably will fit better side by side with some kind of "box" that you my have with your station.
I have one antenna (and the magnetic base also) like the second one but I use it for another purpose.
That antenna although have a little (if any at all) gain, do have enough bandwidth for getting 433Mhz acceptably. The cable length, won't be such a problem unless you have severe radio interference around.
The latest one, I never tested that model although already tested the "model". It will perform better - in my opinion - when mounted in vertical position, not on horizontal like the photo may suggest.
Anyway, the actual results, it will depend every time by your own conditions, like interference that you may have, location, distance, etc etc ...
The ideal would be test it all, but obviously, you won't be interested on that
Hope that this post will help you somehow ...
I think that I could give a better answer, so, I will try to add some info based on what I already experienced.
The first antenna in my opinion will do the job if the TX is not that far away form the RX and at the same time, probably will fit better side by side with some kind of "box" that you my have with your station.
I have one antenna (and the magnetic base also) like the second one but I use it for another purpose.
That antenna although have a little (if any at all) gain, do have enough bandwidth for getting 433Mhz acceptably. The cable length, won't be such a problem unless you have severe radio interference around.
The latest one, I never tested that model although already tested the "model". It will perform better - in my opinion - when mounted in vertical position, not on horizontal like the photo may suggest.
Anyway, the actual results, it will depend every time by your own conditions, like interference that you may have, location, distance, etc etc ...
The ideal would be test it all, but obviously, you won't be interested on that
Hope that this post will help you somehow ...