Comparative shelter for probe t° - Printable Version

+- WeatherDuino Forum (https://www.meteocercal.info/forum)
+-- Forum: Weather Equipment - General Discussion (https://www.meteocercal.info/forum/forum-12.html)
+--- Forum: Weather Stations, Info and Docs (https://www.meteocercal.info/forum/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: Comparative shelter for probe t° (/thread-1199.html)

---

Comparative shelter for probe t° - tobyportugal - 22-08-2017

Hello

Here comparative interesting on the shelter for temperature measurement.





LSOC: They is largest of Stevenson 
SCAE: The Italian shelter
SDAV: It is Davis 7714
SSOC: Socrima with cups of MF
VDAV: Davis ventilated méca 24:00/24h (solar)
VEIG: They are the other specimens of the German shelter ventilated méca.
VTHY: It is Thygan ventilated méca very good in Switzerland on snow and the ice, but with the street in the desert!
VYOU: it is ventilated the méca model


My lack of control of English do not allow me to develop the comments.
The 7714 is a very good compromise.
For the areas “cold” Thygan is excellent.

Good evening

---

RE: Comparative shelter for probe t° - danner - 23-08-2017

From my research I decided on the Davis 7714. It is what I am using for my temp/humidity sensor.

---

RE: Comparative shelter for probe t° - zitoune - 23-08-2017

Hi tobyportugal,

This is a very interesting set of data. Do you have the source by chance?

I think most of the users here are using the Davis 7714 or something similar; that's widely available and relatively small to install.
Its standard deviation is relatively small on this graph with a slight negative offset, which means it's slightly (0.1/0.2 deg C) underestimate the "real" temperature - do you know what is the reference in this comparison?

Thanks
Zitoune

---

RE: Comparative shelter for probe t° - tobyportugal - 23-08-2017

(23-08-2017, 01:53)danner Wrote:  From my research I decided on the Davis 7714. It is what I am using for my temp/humidity sensor.

Hello,

With the price on your premise (the USA), there is no hesitation.

Unfortunately in Europe, it is much more expensive (except if one makes a purchase with several people in the USA)

---

RE: Comparative shelter for probe t° - tobyportugal - 23-08-2017

(23-08-2017, 02:21)zitoune Wrote:  Hi tobyportugal,

This is a very interesting set of data. Do you have the source by chance?

I think most of the users here are using the Davis 7714 or something similar; that's widely available and relatively small to install.
Its standard deviation is relatively small on this graph with a slight negative offset, which means it's slightly (0.1/0.2 deg C) underestimate the "real" temperature - do you know what is the reference in this comparison?

Thanks
Zitoune

Hello,

The source is an intervention (rather old) on InfoClimat.
http://forums.infoclimat.fr/f/topic/13416-surchauffe-davis-vantage-pro-2/?_fromLogin=1&_fromLogout=1
See the answers of Christian P, I asked for the links of the full reports. If I receive the links, I will post them here.
Infoclimat is generally a good information source, one can simply be disappointed exclusiveness brought to the VP2.


The goal of my future WeatherDuino is to assemble comparison tests. (Je ne suis pas sorti de l'auberge )

---

RE: Comparative shelter for probe t° - JT118 - 23-08-2017

Probably the cheapest new 7714 even with post and import duty.

https://www.scaledinstruments.com/product/davis-7714-passive-radiation-shield/

---

RE: Comparative shelter for probe t° - tobyportugal - 24-08-2017

(23-08-2017, 23:07)JT118 Wrote:  Probably the cheapest new 7714 even with post and import duty.

https://www.scaledinstruments.com/product/davis-7714-passive-radiation-shield/

Hello,

I know, but to be interesting 5 parts are needed.

1 part: 110$ = 93€ + 23% VAT PORTUGAL = 114€ (less expensive in France, Germany, Holland!)

5 parts: 375$ = 318€ +23% VAT PORTUGAL = 391€ - > 78.20€/pc

 So of Portuguese are interested for a purchase in group…

---

RE: Comparative shelter for probe t° - JT118 - 24-08-2017

These are excellent,

http://www.metspec.net/unaspirated-radiation-shields

---

RE: Comparative shelter for probe t° - tobyportugal - 02-04-2021

Hello,

My Italian friends are crazier than me....
This online comparison is an excellent database with expensive and low cost instruments.

http://www.kwos.org/comparison/

---

RE: Comparative shelter for probe t° - hornychz - 02-04-2021

(02-04-2021, 05:42)tobyportugal Wrote:  This online comparison is an excellent database with expensive and low cost instruments.

https://www.kwos.org/comparison/

---